THE TANDEM PROJECT
http://www.tandemproject.com.
info@tandemproject.com

UNITED NATIONS, HUMAN RIGHTS,
FREEDOM OF RELIGION OR BELIEF

The Tandem Project is a UN NGO in Special Consultative Status with the
Economic and Social Council of the United Nations

Separation of Religion or Belief and State

The U.N. Official Documentation System (ODS) below the blue bar often will not allow access from some computer browsers to the reports. These reports can all be accessed by clicking on the U.N. Office of High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) web site and then on Universal Periodic Review under Useful Information in the upper left-hand corner.

http://www.ohchr.org/EN/countries/ENACARegion/Pages/KZIndex.aspx

NATIONAL REPORT: 17 NGOs participated in consultation workshops on the report, there is a standing invitation to all Special Rapporteur for country visits, a National Plan of Action for Human Rights 2009-2012) has been prepared, a permanent secretariat for world and traditional religious leaders prepared interfaith dialogue in 2003, 2006, 2009.

COMPILATION OF U.N. INFORMATION: Complete compilation of reports on the country, report implementation or application of international humanitarian law, scope of obligations, cooperation with treaty-bodies, cooperation with special procededures, non-traditional religions not accorded same freedom as traditional religions, footnote 2 reports of UNESCO, UNHCR, UNICEF, UNIFEM and UNODC.

SUMMARY OF STAKEHOLDER LETTERS: Click on footnote 3 to read all Stakeholder Letters. Becket Fund for Religious Liberty and Forum 18 are critical of the Committee on Religious Affairs and described alleged instances of discrimination of non-traditional religions as “sects” including Jehovah’s Witnesses, Baptist Council of Churches, Hare Krishna, Pentacostals, Adventists, non-Sunni Muslims, Scientologists.  Kazakh government did not give permission to OSCE to publish report critical of new Laws on Religion. Forum 18 believes restrictive new Laws on Ammendments and Additions will be re-introduced after 2010 and Kazakhstan’s Chair of OSCE.

U.N. HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR HUMAN RIGHTS REPORT: OHCHR website for Kazakhstan, status of ratifications, reporting status, most recent treaty-bodies concluding observations, most recent special procedures reports, full list of documents, news archive, country visits by special procedures, external links, universal periodic review.

WORKING GROUP REPORT: There were 54 Inter-active Dialogue presentations by Member States. Click to open related interactive-archives to listen to adoption of working group report). There were 102 recommendations including; establish National Institute of Human Rights under the Paris Principles (Germany), continue interfaith harmony conferences for world and traditional religions (Algeria), increase participation of women (Cuba), invite a visit of Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief (United States), consider changing Law for registration of non-traditional religious groups and revise tendency to repression of free speech and restrictions on web-based media (Norway).

U.S. INTERNATIONAL RELIGIOUS FREEDOM REPORT: Paragraphs highlighted in the report below (IV. Freedom of Religion or Belief): nonbelievers, Law on Public Associations, SAMK, headed by chief mufti in Almaty, appointing heads of religious associations, national religion law, religious training of a child, Program for Ensuring Religious Freedom and Improvement of Relations between the Government and Religions, National Action Plan for Human Rights for 2009-2012), policy not to seek or accept registration, media outlets, threat to national security because to promotes pro-American ideology, religious studies course introduced in high school curricula, population wary of minority religious groups and groups that proselytize, government considers “traditional,” contact with NGOs that followed religious freedom topics. *

TANDEM FORUMS: Invitations to build global awareness of international human rights law on freedom of religion or belief in local areas as a follow-up to Universal Periodic Reviews.  They may assess interest, exchange information and consider local partnerships within and between countries as best practice models for international human rights law on freedom of religion or belief. Tandem Forums are held or proposed for Places of Worship, Academic Discourse, Schools, Women and Civil Society.

III.

THE TANDEM PROJECT RECOMMENDATIONS

1. Forum for Civil Society on Human Rights & Freedom of Religion or Belief.  The Tandem Project proposes partnering a Forum for Civil Society on Human Rights & Freedom of Religion or Belief be held in four cities: Almaty, Kazakhstan; Brussels, Belgium;  Oslo, Norway; and Minneapolis, Minnesota-  to include Governments and Non-governmental organizations, Religious and Non-religious beliefs, Traditional and Non-traditional Religions and other members of Civil Society. The Tandem Project Forum proposed agenda would review the National Report and Working Group Recommendations for the Kazakhstan Universal Periodic Review, and Side Events Recommendations made at the Supplementary Human Dimension Meeting on Freedom of Religion or Belief held by the Organization of Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) in Vienna on 9-10 December 2010.  Organizations from each city will be invited to partner a Forum for Civil Society on Human Rights & Freedom of Religion or Belief. 

Organizations invited to partner in a Forum for Civil Society on Human Rights & Freedom of Religion or Belief in Almaty, Kazakhstan include: Almaty Helsinki Committee, Association for Religious Organization of Kazakhstan, Kazakhstan Bureau of International Human Rights and Rule of Law, and Kazakh Government Departments. In Brussels, Belgium they include; European Humanist Federation, Human Rights Without Borders. In Oslo, Norway they include: Norwegian Helsinki Committee, Norwegian Mission to the East, Forum 18, Oslo Center for Peace and Human Rights, Oslo Coalition on Freedom of Religion or Belief. In Minneapolis, Minnesota they include: The Tandem Project, University of Minnesota Human Rights Center, University of Minnesota Hubert H. Humphrey Institute for Public Affairs.

These organizations have not been approached or asked for an endorsement.  They may be contacted in the future by The Tandem Project Forum for Civil Society to assess interest, exchange information and consider a partnership as a best practice model on international human rights law and freedom of religion or belief.

This quote (below) is from the Schedule of Side Events that took place during the Supplementary Human Dimension Meeting on Freedom of Religion or Belief held by the Office for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) in Vienna on 9-10 December 2010 in Vienna. Two Side Events took place of interest to The Tandem Project Recommendation on Thursday, 9 December: Pluralism, Relativism and the Rule of Law by the European Humanist Federation, and Broken Promises – Freedom of Religion or Belief in Kazakhstan by the Norwegian Helsinki Committee/Norwegian Mission to the East/Forum 18/Oslo Center for Peace and Human Rights/Oslo Coalition on Freedom of Religion or Belief.

• “The Helsinki Document of 1992 (Chapter IV) called for increasing the openness of OSCE activities and expanding the role of NGOs. In particular, in paragraph (15) of Chapter IV the participating States decided to facilitate during OSCE meetings informal discussion meetings between representatives of participating States and of NGOs, and to provide encouragement to NGOs organizing seminars on OSCE related issues. In line with this decision, NGOs, governments, and other participants are encouraged to organize side meetings on relevant issues of their choice.”   

OSCE Supplemental Human Dimension Meeting on Freedom of Religion or Belief, Vienna
http://www.osce.org/odihr/documents/73963

Summary: Pluralism, Relativism and the Rule of Law: “Pluralism, the freedom to choose one’s world view is comprising religious or non-religious beliefs and to live one’s life accordingly, is a tenent of our democracies and a condition for social harmony.  Does the utter condemnation of relativism by Catholic leaders as well as by some MPs relate to pluralism? If yes, in what way? The European Humanist Federation, together with its Italian member association UAAR (Unione degli Atei e degli Agnostici razionalisti) wishes to discuss with government and NGO representatives and with OSCE/ODIHR officials the meaning and scope of pluralism in states governed by the rule of law.”

Summary: Broken Promises – Freedom of Religion or Belief in Kazakhstan: “It will present some conclusions of a project documenting freedom of religion or belief issues in Kazakhstan. It will focus on some of the key issues detected as obstacles to progress in strengthening freedom of religion and present some recommendations for improvements. Kazakh authorities have been invited to give a presentation on their policies in the filed and efforts throughout the Chairmanship. The report, updating the picture on some of the main problems in the filed from a grassroots perspective, will be re-launched at the side event, which will also address the situation with freedom of religion during the Chairmanship. A group of Norwegian human rights organizations has cooperated on a project addressing freedom of religion or belief in Kazakhstan. The project consists of documenting and publishing a report on these issues, as well as entering into dialogue with authorities and civil society organizations on how to strengthen respect for relevant human rights.”

The Tandem Project supports the United States recommendation to Kazakhstan in the Working Group Report to invite the Special Rapporteur on Freedom of Religion or Belief to visit as a follow-up to their Universal Periodic Review. 

The Tandem Project Background information on international human rights law and freedom of religion or belief is attached to this document.

2.  Forum for Academic Discourse on Human Rights & Freedom of Religion or Belief. The Tandem Project Forum proposes a partnership with academic institutions in these cities – Almaty, Brussels, Oslo and Minneapolis as a follow-up to the Kazakhstan Universal Periodic Review.  These Forums would be a multi-disciplinary academic approaches to carry out the U.N. Human Rights Council draft plan of action for the second phase (2010-2014) of the World Programs for Human Rights Education (A/HRC/15/28).

Draft plan of action for the second phase (2010-2014) of the World Programme for Human Rights Education (A/HRC/15/28): U.N. Human Rights Council

(b) Teaching and learning processes and tools

27. Introducing or improving human rights education in the higher education system requires adopting a holistic approach to teaching and learning, by integrating programme objectives and content, resources, methodologies, assessment and evaluation; by looking beyond the classroom and the higher-education institution to society; and by building partnerships between different members of the academic community and beyond.

(v) Develop multidisciplinary and interdisciplinary human rights academic programmes. 20

²⁰ Multidisciplinary programmes would include the study, research and engagement with human rights from different disciplinary perspectives, such as philosophy, sociology, languages, international and domestic law, etc. Interdisciplinary programmes would entail the crossing of boundaries between disciplines and the pooling of approaches and methodologies to study, research and engage with human rights with a new integrated perspective.

Academic institutions invited to partner in a Tandem Forum would include: Al Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty, Kazakhstan; University of Oslo, Oslo, Norway; Free University of Brussels (French Speaking & Dutch Speaking), Brussels, Belgium, University of Minnesota, United States of America.

These academic institutions have not been approached or asked for an endorsement.  They may be contacted by The Tandem Project Forum to assess interest, exchange information and consider a partnership as a best practice model for international human rights law on freedom of religion or belief.

• There can be no adequate understanding of the most important issues we face when disciplines are cloistered from one another and operate on their own premises. It would be far more effective to bring together people working on questions of religion, politics, history, economics, anthropology, sociology, literature, art, religion and philosophy to engage in comparative analysis of common problems. As the curriculum is restructured, fields of inquiry and methods of investigation will be transformed.

– New York Times Op-Ed, Higher Education – Collaboration Rather Than Specialization; Mark C. Taylor, Chairman of the Religion Department, Columbia University, New York. 

IV.

FREEDOM OF RELIGION OR BELIEF

* The Tandem Project bolds paragraphs of interest for follow-up recommendations. Bolding paragraphs are not endorsed by the U.S. State Department.

U.S. State Department 2010 International Religious Freedom Report, Kazakhstan

Links to State Department sites are welcomed. Unless a copyright is indicated, information on the State Department’s main website is in the public domain and may be copied and distributed without permission. Citation of the U.S. State Department as source of the information is appreciated.

http://www.state.gov/g/drl/rls/irf/2010/148793.htm

November 17, 2010

The constitution provides for freedom of religion, but the government's religion laws limit the legal protections of religious freedom in the constitution.

There was no change in the status of respect for religious freedom by the government during the reporting period. There was no change in the laws governing religious activity. The government's enforcement of current laws led to continuing problems for some unregistered groups, as the laws impose mandatory registration requirements on missionaries and religious organizations. While the majority of religious communities worshipped largely without government interference, local officials attempted on occasion to limit some minority groups' practice of religion. Local and national law enforcement authorities increasingly prosecuted nontraditional religious groups for conducting illegal or unsanctioned educational, religious, or entrepreneurial activities. The government did not overtly criticize "nontraditional religious groups." However, amid increased government-generated rhetoric on the need to fight "religious extremism," the number of religious group members accused of terrorism increased.

There were no reports of societal abuses or discrimination based on religious affiliation, belief, or practice. Muslim, Russian Orthodox, Roman Catholic, and Jewish leaders reported high levels of acceptance in society. Some minority religious groups, including evangelical Christians and Scientologists, faced negative media coverage.

The U.S. government discusses religious freedom with the government as part of its overall policy to promote human rights. The ambassador and other U.S. officials engaged in extensive private and public dialogue with the government to urge that any amendments to the religion laws be consistent with the country's constitutional guarantees of religious freedom and with its international commitments. U.S. government officials visited religious facilities, met with religious leaders, and worked with government officials to address specific cases of concern. Embassy officials maintained contact with a broad range of religious groups and religious freedom advocates.

Section I. Religious Demography

The country has an area of 1,052,540 square miles and a population of 16.4 million, according to preliminary results of the 2009 national census. Due in part to the country's nomadic and Soviet past, many residents describe themselves as nonbelievers; surveys from past years suggested low levels of religious conviction and worship attendance. The government maintains statistics on the number of registered congregations and organizations but not on the size of each group. The most recent reliable statistics on religious affiliation are based on the 1999 census.

Although there was a large increase in the number of minority religious congregations registered since 1999, the government believes that percentages of the population belonging to particular religious groups have remained consistent.

Approximately 65 percent of the population professes to be Muslim. Ethnic Kazakhs, who constitute an estimated 60 percent of the population, and ethnic Uzbeks, Uighurs, and Tatars, who collectively make up less than 10 percent, are historically Sunni Muslims of the Hanafi school. Other Islamic groups that account for less than 1 percent of the population include Shafi'i Sunni (traditionally associated with Chechens), Shi'a, Sufi, and Ahmadi. The highest concentration of self-identified practicing Muslims is in the southern region bordering Uzbekistan. There were 2,369 registered mosques, most affiliated with the Spiritual Association of Muslims of Kazakhstan (SAMK), a national organization with close ties to the government. Approximately 70 mosques are not affiliated with the SAMK.

Approximately one-third of the population, comprising sizeable numbers of ethnic Russians and smaller populations of ethnic Ukrainians and ethnic Belarusians, are Russian Orthodox by tradition. There were 299 registered Russian Orthodox churches. Members of a Roman Catholic archdiocese include ethnic Ukrainians and ethnic Germans and account for 1 percent of the population. An estimated 1.3 percent is ethnic German, many of whom are Roman Catholic or Lutheran. The government reported 83 registered Roman Catholic churches and affiliated organizations throughout the country. A smaller, affiliated community of Greek Catholics, many of whom are ethnic Ukrainians, had five registered churches.

According to government statistics, Protestant Christian congregations outnumber Russian Orthodox or Roman Catholic congregations, although it is unlikely that Protestant Christians account for a larger number of adherents. During the reporting period the government reported 1,267 registered Protestant Christian organizations with 543 places of worship.

There are two Baptist groups in the country: the Union of Evangelical Christians and Baptists (Union of Baptists), with an estimated 10,000 adherents and 227 registered groups, and the Council of Churches of Evangelical Christians and Baptists (Council of Churches) with as many as 1,000 adherents. The Council of Churches refuses to register on principle.

Other Christian religious groups with a sizable number of congregations include Presbyterians, Lutherans, and Pentecostals, as well as Jehovah's Witnesses and Seventh-day Adventists. Smaller communities of Methodists, Mennonites, and Mormons also are registered.

A Jewish community, estimated at less than 1 percent of the population, has synagogues in Almaty, Astana, Ust-Kamenogorsk, Kostanai, and Pavlodar.

According to government statistics, 43 other registered religious groups during the reporting period, including four registered Buddhist groups, 12 affiliates of the Hare Krishna movement, the Church of Scientology, Baha'is, Christian Scientists, and the Unification Church.

Section II. Status of Government Respect for Religious Freedom

Legal/Policy Framework

The constitution provides for freedom of religion; however, other laws and policies narrow these rights in practice. The constitution defines the country as a secular state and provides the right to decline religious affiliation.

The government's religion laws narrow the legal protections of religious freedom found in the constitution, and 2005 amendments to the laws reinforce registration requirements. They also clarify that religious groups must register with both the central government and local governments of individual regions (oblasts) in which they have congregations. To register, a religious organization must have at least 10 members and submit an application to the Ministry of Justice (MOJ). Religion legislation continues to provide that all persons are free to practice their religion "alone or together with others."

The government may deny registration based upon an insufficient number of adherents or inconsistencies between the provisions of a religious organization's charter and the law. In addition, under the Law on Public Associations, a registered organization, including a religious group, may have all activities suspended by court order for a period of three to six months for defiance of the constitution or laws or for systematic pursuit of activities that contradict the charter and bylaws of the organization as registered. Police, procurators, and citizens may petition a court to suspend the activities of a registered organization for failure to rectify violations or for repeated violations of the law. During a suspension, the organization is prohibited from speaking with the media; holding meetings, gatherings, or services; and undertaking financial transactions other than continued contractual obligations such as paying salaries.

Administrative code article 375 allows authorities to suspend the activities and fine the leaders of unregistered groups; article 374-1, a related provision added to the administrative code by the July 2005 national security amendments, carries significantly heavier fines than article 375. Operating an unregistered religious organization is subject to a fine of $961 (141,300 tenge) and participating in an unregistered religious organization is subject to a fine of $481(70,650 tenge). Local authorities have broad discretion in determining whether to file charges for unregistered religious activity under articles 375 or 374-1.

The Religious Issues Committee (RIC), which was transferred in March 2010 from the MOJ to the Ministry of Culture, serves as a liaison between religious groups and the government. In addition the RIC consults with the MOJ to facilitate the registration of religious groups. The RIC also provides expert testimony to courts on religious issues, reviews religious materials law enforcement officials obtain in their investigations, and coordinates with law enforcement officials to monitor compliance with registration requirements.

During the reporting period, government officials continued to express concern regarding the potential spread of political and religious extremism in the country. The Committee for National Security (KNB) has characterized the fight against "religious extremism" as a top priority of the internal intelligence service. A 2005 extremism law, which applies to religious groups and other organizations, gives the government broad latitude in identifying and designating a group as an extremist organization, banning a designated group's activities, and criminalizing membership in a banned organization. The Hizb ut-Tahrir (HT) political movement remained the only group banned under the law. HT is an extremist Islamist political organization motivated by a socioreligious ideology that is virulently anti-Semitic and anti-Western and calls for the overthrow of secular governments. No apolitical religious organizations in the country have been outlawed as extremist.

The government observes Orthodox Christmas and Kurban-Ait as national holidays.

The elections law prohibits political parties based upon ethnicity, gender, or religious affiliation. The criminal code prohibits the incitement of interethnic or interreligious hatred; this law has on one occasion been subject to broad interpretation that included some religious teachings.

The SAMK, headed by the chief mufti in Almaty, exercises significant influence over the practice of Islam, including the construction of mosques and the administration of examinations and background checks for aspiring imams. The SAMK is the primary coordinator of Hajj travel and authorizes travel agencies to provide Hajj travel services to citizens. Religious observers report that the SAMK occasionally pressures nonaligned imams and congregations to join the SAMK to ensure liturgical orthodoxy. Notwithstanding SAMK influence and pressure, there were some registered Muslim communities unaffiliated with the SAMK.

Local and foreign missionaries must register annually with the MOJ and provide information on religious affiliation, territory of missionary work, and time period for conducting that work. All literature and other materials to support missionary work must be provided with the registration application; use of materials not vetted during the registration process is illegal. In addition a missionary must produce registration documents and power of attorney from the sponsoring religious organization to be allowed to work on its behalf. The MOJ may refuse registration to missionaries whose work would be inconsistent with any law, including laws prohibiting the incitement of interethnic or interreligious hatred. Foreign missionaries, like all visitors, are required to register with the migration police and indicate the purpose of their stay. The constitution requires foreign religious associations to conduct their activities, including appointing the heads of religious associations, "in coordination with appropriate state institutions." Foreigners may register religious organizations; however, the government requires that the majority of the 10 founders be local citizens.

Beginning March 1 the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and the Ministry of the Interior introduced new visa regulations which require a foreigner who works for religious organizations to obtain a missionary visa. Missionary visas only permit a person to stay in the country for a maximum of six months per 12-month period. The new procedures require the RIC to vet applicants, and their visa applications must be accompanied by an RIC-issued letter of approval. Missionary visa applicants must obtain RIC clearance every time they apply for visas.

The government does not permit religious instruction in public schools. Homeschooling is permitted only in certain circumstances, which do not include religiously based motivations. Parents may enroll children in supplemental religious education classes provided by registered religious organizations.

Under the national religion law, religious training of a child should not cause damage to a child's all-around development, physical, or moral health. The laws do not clarify how such damage should be assessed or which agency would make such a determination. Educational licensing regulations do not permit religious groups to educate children without approval from the Ministry of Education. In accordance with the regulations, a religious organization whose charter includes provisions for religious education may be denied registration if it does not obtain approval from the Ministry of Education.

The government exempts registered religious organizations from taxes on church collections and income from certain religious activities. Congregations are required to pay for services such as fire company protection for religious buildings. The government has donated buildings and land and provided other assistance for the construction of new mosques, synagogues, and Russian Orthodox churches.

Procurators have the right to inspect annually all organizations registered with state bodies, and they regularly conducted such inspections.

On November 26, 2008, parliament passed amendments to the religion law that civil society activists and religious groups widely opposed as severe restrictions of religious freedom. The proposed legislation was sent for signature to the president, who first submitted it to the Constitutional Council for review. On February 11, 2009, the council struck down the legislation, ruling on technical grounds that the amendments were unconstitutional.

The 2007-09 Program for Ensuring Religious Freedom and Improvement of Relations between the Government and Religions, approved by the government in 2007, provides a set of guidelines and plans for the government's activities in the sphere of religion. Among other things, the program outlines plans for "increasing the stability of the religious situation" and preventing religious extremism through a variety of educational efforts and government-sponsored articles and programs in media outlets. In addition the program criticizes increasingly active "nontraditional religious groups" for causing tension in interfaith relations and ignoring existing social, cultural, and religious traditions. The program calls for new legislation to increase control over missionaries and over the dissemination of religious materials.

The National Action Plan on Human Rights for 2009-12, signed by the president in June 2009, noted several gaps, in particular penalties, between Kazakhstani legislation and international standards on religious freedom and for unregistered religious activities. It also proposed that by 2011 the country should amend its religious legislation to bring it in line with international standards. In addition, the report recommended that the MOJ, in collaboration with nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), begin to publish an annual report on religious freedom. As of June 30, the report has not been published.

The government continued to express publicly its support for religious tolerance and diversity.

Restrictions on Religious Freedom

The government generally enforced existing legal restrictions on religious freedom. However, no apolitical religious groups were banned.

The Hizb ut-Tahrir (HT) Islamist political movement remained banned under the extremism law. Because HT is primarily a political organization, albeit motivated by religious ideology, and because it does not condemn terrorist acts by other groups, authorities' actions to restrict HT and prosecute its members are not a restriction on religious freedom per se.

Most religious communities choose to register with the government and are ultimately successful in obtaining registration; however, minority religious groups sometimes reported long delays. When it refused or significantly delayed registration, the government usually claimed a group's charter did not meet the requirements of the law or cited the need to refer it for expert theological review.

The majority of religious groups worshiped largely without government interference; however, local and regional officials attempted on occasion to limit or control several groups' practice of religion, especially minority religious communities such as evangelical Christians, Jehovah's Witnesses, Scientologists, and Muslims not affiliated with the SAMK. The government applied laws governing unregistered religious groups unevenly during the reporting period.

During the reporting period, the Baptist Council of Churches noted several court cases against churchgoers throughout the country for participating in the activities of an unregistered group. The council of churches has a policy not to seek or accept registration in former Soviet countries, and church members criticized the intrusive nature of the registration process that requires information about ethnicity, family status, religious education, employment, and political affiliation.

The council reported several instances in which pastors were fined for unregistered religious activities and were subsequently arrested for failure to pay the fines. In all the cases, the terms of confinement were either suspended or limited to three days in jail.

The New Life Church reported several instances of followers being sanctioned for unregistered missionary activity. School authorities in Aktau fired a teacher for passing religious literature to a student, and local authorities subsequently fined the teacher for unregistered missionary activities. On June 9, 2010, Kyzylorda district court suspended for six months the activities of the Aktau branch of the New Life Protestant Church and fined the church's pastor, Maxim Tashenov, for unregistered missionary activity. The church is registered with the local authorities in neighboring Mangistau region, but not in Kyzylorda. The court sanctioned the church because Pastor Tashenov led a prayer meeting in Kyzyorda.

According to the Almaty Helsinki Committee, on March 11, 2010, the Taraz district court fined an Adventist, Aleksandr Orphonidi, for inappropriate upbringing of his 12-year-old daughter because she did not attend school on Saturdays.

There were reports that local representatives of the KNB or police disrupted religious meetings in private homes during the reporting period. Several groups reported that local law enforcement representatives attended their services, although their presence generally was not considered disruptive.

Although the law is vague on the definition of missionary activity, authorities frequently interpreted any religious activity by visiting foreigners as missionary activity and expelled those who were not registered as missionaries.

Ahmadi Muslims reported that one of their foreign missionaries had to leave the country following the introduction of new visa requirements. His application for a new missionary visa was pending at the end of the reporting period.

On March 10, 2010, the Supreme Court overturned the May 2008 deportation order against a U.S. citizen, who was a member of the governing body of Jehovah's Witnesses, and a Canadian citizen. Both had been deported after courts ruled that they had violated the terms of their business visas by conducting missionary activities without registration.

Where religious groups operated legal entities, such as collective farms, restaurants, or orphanages, authorities conducted health, sanitation, and other inspections relevant to the nature of the entities' operations. Authorities conducted public safety inspections of premises used for religious worship to ensure compliance with building and fire codes. These inspections also provided authorities with information about the registration status of the groups.

Local authorities in Almaty launched a criminal investigation on May 17, 2010 against the pastor of Fares Protestant Church, Valerian Kogay. Law enforcement agents twice raided the church-run rehabilitation center for drug addicts, and the authorities are investigating Pastor Kogay for illegal entrepreneurship and medical treatment. The investigation was continuing at the end of the reporting period.

Several media outlets continued to publish or broadcast stories critical of nontraditional religious groups such as evangelical Protestant Christians, Jehovah's Witnesses, Scientologists, and Hare Krishnas, depicting them as dangerous sects harmful to society. Between December 2009 and February 2010, local affiliates of the Nur-Media holding company, a media company controlled by the ruling Nur Otan party, ran a series of television programs critical of nontraditional groups in South Kazakhstan. The government created and funded an NGO, "Assistance to Victims of Totalitarian Sects." The NGO publicly identified several nontraditional religious groups as "sects." Credible NGOs and nontraditional religious groups criticized a textbook on religious studies that was intended for inclusion in high school curricula as biased against nontraditional religious groups. The Ministry of Culture declined the book as inappropriate, although copies of it still circulated in some high schools.

According to media sources, the Akmola Department of Interior organized a seminar on March 2, 2010, on countering religious extremism, during which the police noted that there were no incidents of terrorism in the Akmola region, but highlighted several cases of administrative fines against unregistered Baptists.

In September 2009 the RIC reversed its decision to ban several Jehovah's Witnesses publications. However, the RIC asked that Jehovah's Witnesses submit its literature for an assessment by RIC experts. The assessment was pending at the end of the reporting period.

In contrast with the previous reporting period, the Karasai regional government near Almaty moved toward an agreement with the Almaty Hare Krishnas over resolution of a dispute regarding a plot of land they had been using in the Almaty region. The government maintained that the dispute was a property dispute unrelated to the religious affiliation of the Hare Krishnas. Several other Hare Krishna communities registered in the country operated without similar problems, although they did not own any property. In March 2009 local authorities offered the Krishnas land close to Almaty for their temple and promised to find pasture land for the community's cows. On April 9 a newly-appointed Akim in the Karasai regional government officially offered the Hare Krishnas one hectare of land, which the group currently occupies. The community requested an additional 15 hectares adjacent to the site. At the end of the reporting period, their request was still pending.

Abuses of Religious Freedom

On April 15, 2010, an appellate court reversed a lower court's ruling and vacated the fine imposed on Zhana-Teresa Raudovich. On January 20, 2010, the court had fined her 100 times the minimum monthly income for hosting a religious meeting without proper registration.

On April 9, 2010, the Akmola district court sentenced Valeriy Tverdokhlebov to four years in prison for inciting social, national, tribal, and religious hatred, and for propagating terrorism. Tverdokhlebov, who follows Salafi Islam, maintained to the court that he confessed under torture.

Viktor Leven, a Kazakhstan-born Baptist, who relinquished his German citizenship but has been unable to gain Kazakhstani citizenship, was convicted on October 14, 2009, of missionary activity without permission and was threatened with deportation. He and his wife lack passports and cannot obtain paid work. At the end of the reporting period, Viktor Leven's and his wife's status had not changed.

In October 2009 the Almaty district court found the president of the Almaty Church of Scientology, Svetlana Baytinger, guilty of engaging in illegal commercial activities and sentenced her to three years of probation. The prosecution had accused the church of illegally profiting from the sale of its literature and using its status as a religious organization to avoid paying taxes. This followed the October 8, 2008, raid on church premises in Almaty and Medeo.

During the reporting period, the government continued to investigate an apparent treason case, involving raids, brief detentions, and a tax evasion trial, against leaders of Grace Presbyterian Church, following an August 27, 2009 KNB raid on the church's headquarters in the city of Karaganda, a Grace Church in Ust Kamenogorsk, and several church-owned private homes. This followed a January 2008 raid on the Almaty Grace Presbyterian Church, a separate congregation. The government released few details of the investigation. In a KNB internal document provided by the Zhambyl Grace Church, a KNB officer of the Zhambyl regional department argued that the church posed a threat to national security because it promotes pro-American ideology and aims to discredit local and federal authorities. Authorities did not formally detain any church officials or close the churches. At the end of the reporting period, no church officials had been charged with treason, although church officials and religious freedom advocates remained alarmed at the breadth and scope of the continuing investigation.

There were no further developments in the case of Elizaveta Drenicheva, a Unification Church member and Russian citizen who was convicted in January 2009 of "instilling a sense of inferiority in citizens based on their tribal association." In March 2009 the Almaty court of appeals had vacated Drenicheva's sentence but did not overturn her guilty verdict.

As in the previous reporting period, there were no reports of prolonged detention of members of religious organizations for proselytizing. On occasion authorities took action against individuals engaged in proselytizing who were not registered as missionaries; however, such actions were limited to the confiscation of religious literature, fines, brief detentions, and deportation.

According to media reports, members of the Tablighi Jama'at Muslim movement, an apolitical Islamic missionary group with origins in South Asia, were detained in the Zhambyl region for illegal missionary activities. The Tablighi Jama'at movement is not registered in the country.

When individuals were found guilty of violating articles 374 or 375 of the administrative code, courts imposed a fine. Council of Churches members usually refused to pay fines for nonregistration. There were reports that courts enforced payment of fines in several cases by seizing property, including private homes owned by pastors and used for worship.

There were no reports of religious prisoners or detainees in the country.

Forced Religious Conversion

There were no reports of forced religious conversion.

Improvements and Positive Developments in Respect for Religious Freedom

An additional 91 religious groups registered with the government during the reporting period. According to government statistics, as of April 1, 2010, 4,453 religious organizations and groups were registered in the country, representing more than 40 confessions and denominations. In September 2009 a religious studies course was introduced in high school curricula.

The government made efforts to promote religious tolerance in its ranks. Human rights training that NGOs provided to law enforcement officers in cooperation with the government continued to include information on religious rights under the law.

Section III. Status of Societal Respect for Religious Freedom

The country is multiethnic, with a long tradition of tolerance and secularism. Since independence, the number of mosques and churches has increased greatly. However, the population is sometimes wary of minority religious groups and groups that proselytize. There were several reports of citizens filing complaints with authorities after their family members became involved with such groups.

Members of the extremist HT political movement continued to print and distribute leaflets that supported anti-Semitism, among other positions.

Leaders of the four religious groups the government considers "traditional" — Islam, Russian Orthodoxy, Roman Catholicism, and Judaism — reported general acceptance and tolerance that other minority religious groups did not always enjoy. During the reporting period, there were no reports that mistrust of minority religious groups led to violence.

Section IV. U.S. Government Policy

The U.S. government discusses religious freedom with the government as part of its overall policy to promote human rights. U.S. officials emphasized that bilateral cooperation on economic and security matters is a complement to, not a substitute for, meaningful progress on human rights, including religious freedom.

The ambassador and other embassy officers, as well as Department of State officials in Washington, remained engaged in dialogue with the government to seek assurance that any amendments ultimately adopted into the religion laws reflect the country's international commitments to respect individuals' rights to peaceful expression of religious beliefs.

Embassy and officials visited houses of worship, met with religious leaders, and worked with government officials to address specific cases of concern.

The embassy maintained contact with a broad range of religious communities and religious freedom advocates, and reported on violations of their constitutional and human rights. Senior Department of State and U.S. government officials met with senior government officials and members of faith-based groups in the country to raise religious freedom concerns. Embassy officials worked to connect religious communities with in-country legal resources to assist with registration concerns.

Embassy officials attended public events in support of religious communities and participated in roundtables and other public debates on matters of religious freedom and tolerance. U.S. government representatives in the country and in Washington were in regular contact with NGOs that followed religious freedom topics, including the Almaty Helsinki Committee, the Association of Religious Organizations of Kazakhstan, and the Kazakhstan Bureau of International Human Rights and Rule of Law.

The embassy's Democracy Commission Small Grants Program provided support to programs promoting human rights and religious tolerance.

The Tandem Project a non-governmental organization (NGO) founded in 1986 to build understanding, tolerance, and respect for diversity of religion or belief, and to prevent discrimination in matters relating to freedom of religion or belief. The Tandem Project has sponsored multiple conferences, curricula, reference material and programs on Article 18 of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights- Everyone shall have the right to freedom of thought, conscience and religion – and the 1981 United Nations Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief.

Documents Attached: Kazakhstan - Universal Periodic Review & Freedom of Religion or Belief; Background - Human Rights & Freedom of Religion or Belief